You Either Have a Rat Problem, Or You Don’t

A food scrap collection program isn’t introducing a new food source into the neighborhood. It’s changing where we put one that was already there.

Food scrap collection is starting to take off in Southeast Michigan. Fifteen communities now offer food scrap drop-off programs, and four collect food scraps at the curb. Another eight are getting programs underway. It’s a great start and we’re going to need many more communities to follow if we’re going to reach our goal of cutting food waste in half by 2030.

But as more communities consider food scrap collection, one concern comes up again and again: “What about the rats?”

The thought of attracting rats, raccoons or other unwelcome guests can stop a program before it even starts. But as Mike Csapo, General Manager of the Resource Recovery and Recycling Authority of Southwest Oakland County (RRRASOC), likes to say, “You either have a rat problem, or you don’t.”

Here’s what he means.

First, your food scraps are already going out to your curb. Banana peels, chicken bones and last week’s leftovers don’t become more attractive to animals because you separated them from the rest of your trash. A food scrap collection program isn’t introducing a new food source into the neighborhood. It’s changing where we put one that was already there.

Second, how food scraps are stored matters more than whether they’re separated. A rat doesn’t care whether yesterday’s pizza crust is headed for a landfill or a compost facility. It cares whether it can get to it. Keep scraps contained and indoors until it’s time to put them out or take them to a drop-off site.

And lastly, different programs have found different ways to make collection work. Some use enclosed carts or locked drop-off containers; others collect food scraps alongside yard waste in paper bags. What matters is minimizing access, avoiding spills and overflow, and collecting material regularly.

None of this means food left accessible to animals won’t attract them. It can, whether that food is in a trash bag, a compost cart or a yard-waste bag. But that’s a waste-storage issue, not something unique to food scrap collection. Separating food scraps doesn’t create a new food source. We’re just taking food that was already being thrown away and managing it differently.

For municipalities considering food scrap collection, rats are something to plan for, not something to fear. Think through containers, collection frequency, site maintenance and clear instructions for residents. Learn from the communities already doing it, and build those lessons into the program from the beginning. The possibility of rodents is a reason for good program design, not a reason to send food scraps to a landfill.

Keep learning

More food waste stories

We believe Detroit can become a zero food waste city. We have a lot to learn…
Involving students in that process can spark leadership, responsible care and valuing of resources, and caring…
Perhaps what has surprised me most, though, is that you don’t have to care about climate…

Continue reading

Browse by category

Policy change

Interviews